History

    The Blue Eagle Tavern is very rich in local & U.S. history.  It has been at its current location since the late 1800s when a barn was hauled by horse and wagon to a dirt road intersection at the top of Italy Hill and established an inn, where hospitality services were provided to stage coaches and Pony Express carriers navigating the scenic mountains and valleys between Canandaigua and Keuka lakes.  At...

The Tavern

Our Song

Bat McGrath recorded the song you are hearing “At the Blue Eagle”. Visit www.batmcgrath.com to find out more about the music of Bat. Bat McGrath Back at the Blue Eagle 2012 Bat will be appearing live at the Blue Eagle for the grand re opening this Summer. Tickets available online soon.

About

My name is Cindy Tucker, the proud new owner of the historic Blue Eagle Tavern.  I take this opportunity to introduce myself to the many patrons I will be meeting after its reopening, and to outline what the wings of the Blue Eagle will soon be carrying to the top of Italy Hill.     FOR YOU LOCAL LONG-TIME REGULARS:  It is you that has kept the Blue Eagle flying for so many years.  Although there will be some...